Choose a comparison that answers one question
Maybe you want to know how consistently you record tips on closing shifts. Or you want to compare the shifts you worked in one venue. Set a time window and use the same definition of tips and hours on both sides. Leave out records you’re still checking rather than silently treating missing amounts as zero.
Keep context alongside the numbers
A special event, shorter hours or different role can explain a gap. Mark those differences in the notes and compare a few ordinary weeks before giving them too much meaning. Don’t compare your own records with another worker’s tips unless the data and context are shared appropriately.
Write a next step that doesn’t assume a forecast
“Keep recording closing shifts for another month” is a useful takeaway. “Weekends always pay more” may not be supported. If you use a personal per-hour comparison, keep the formula and what you included clear. Review again later with the same definitions.
Your small, useful checklist
A fair review tells you what your records can say and what they still cannot.